| 1879-1880 | Samuel L. McKee (faculty) | 1924-1925 | Robert L. Myers |
| 1891-1893 | Walter L. Berry | ||
| 1894 | Messler | 1926-1927 | Harold S. Ofstie |
| 1895 | Lowndes | 1928 | Boise Potthoff |
| 1896-1897 | H. McC. Anderson | 1929-1937 | Ed Kubale |
| 1898 | Dick Van Winkle | 1938-1941 | Quinn Decker |
| 1899 | Edgar Tanner | 1942 | Laird Holt |
| 1900 | Hamill | 1943-1945 | Centre did not field a team |
| 1901 | Hall | 1946-1950 | Carl Anderson |
| 1902 | E. M. Tutwiler | 1951 | William L. Crabtree |
| 1903-1904 | H. A. Chiles | 1952-1956 | Briscoe Inman |
| 1905-1908 | William E. Johnston | 1957-1960 | Joe Brummett |
| 1909-1911 | M. Beale Banks | 1961-1962 | Spencer Holt |
| 1912-1913 | Patrick O’Brien | 1963-1965 | Briscoe Inman |
| 1914 | Merle C. Knapp | 1966-1971 | Steele Harmon |
| 1915 | Orville B. Littick | 1972-1979 | Herb McGuire |
| 1916 | Robert L. Myers | 1980-1997 | Joe McDaniel |
| 1917-1923 | Charles Moran | 1998- | Andrew Frye |